ABA Formal Opinion 512: What It Says About AI, Rule by Rule
Short answer: ABA Formal Opinion 512 says lawyers may use generative AI if they meet the duties they already have: understand the tool, protect client information, tell clients when the situation calls for it, review what it produces, bill fairly and supervise everyone who uses it. Its sharpest point is consent: for tools that can learn from what they are given, the client's informed consent is needed before information about the representation goes in.
ABA Formal Opinion 512, "Generative Artificial Intelligence Tools" was issued by the ABA Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility on July 29, 2024. It is 15 pages long and is the national starting point for lawyers using AI. Page numbers below are the opinion's own printed page numbers.
Two limits apply to everything on this page. The opinion interprets the ABA Model Rules as amended through August 2023 (p. 2, n. 4), and the Model Rules bind no one until a state adopts them, so your state's rules and opinions control. The opinion also says its view on informed consent "is based on the risks and capabilities of GAI tools as of the publication of this opinion" (p. 7, n. 34).
"GAI" in the quotations means generative artificial intelligence.
Do I have to understand how an AI tool works before I use it?
Yes, to a reasonable degree. Rule 1.1 does not make you an AI expert, but it does require a reasonable understanding of what the specific tool can and cannot do, kept up to date.
You also have to review what the tool produces. How much checking is needed depends on the tool and the task, but the opinion is clear that relying on output without review can breach the duty of competence:
"a lawyer's reliance on, or submission of, a GAI tool's output-without an appropriate degree of independent verification or review of its output-could violate the duty to provide competent representation as required by Model Rule 1.1." (pp. 3-4)
Responsibility stays with you whatever level of review you choose, and professional judgment cannot be handed to the tool:
"regardless of the level of review the lawyer selects, the lawyer is fully responsible for the work on behalf of the client." (p. 4)
Can I put client information into an AI tool?
Only after weighing the risk that people outside the firm, or people inside it behind an ethical wall, could see it. For "self-learning" tools, which can reuse what they are given, Opinion 512 says you need the client's informed consent first.
"a client's informed consent is required prior to inputting information relating to the representation into such a GAI tool." (p. 7)
General boilerplate in an engagement letter does not count:
"merely adding general, boiler-plate provisions to engagement letters purporting to authorize the lawyer to use GAI is not sufficient." (p. 7)
At a minimum, read the tool's terms, or have someone qualified read them for you:
"all lawyers should read and understand the Terms of Use, privacy policy, and related contractual terms and policies of any GAI tool they use" (p. 7)
The purpose is to "learn who has access to the information that the lawyer inputs into the tool" (p. 7). Consent is not needed when no client information goes in, for example when you use the tool to brainstorm ideas (p. 7). For more, see Confidentiality and privilege.
Do I have to tell my client I used AI?
It depends on the facts. Rule 1.4 requires you to disclose or consult in specific situations, and to disclose whenever the client asks.
The opinion lists the situations (pp. 8-9). Disclose when the client asks, when the engagement terms or outside-counsel guidelines require it, or when client information will go into the tool. Consult the client when AI use affects the fee, or when AI output will shape a significant decision, such as evaluating likely outcomes or jury selection.
"lawyers must disclose their GAI practices if asked by a client how they conducted their work, or whether GAI technologies were employed in doing so" (p. 8)
Can I bill a client for time spent using AI?
Yes, for the time you actually spent, such as writing prompts and reviewing the draft. You may not bill hourly clients for the time the tool saved.
"lawyers who bill clients an hourly rate for time spent on a matter must bill for their actual time." (p. 12)
Flat fees get the same scrutiny. If AI makes the work much faster, the usual flat fee may no longer be reasonable:
"it may be unreasonable under Rule 1.5 for the lawyer to charge the same flat fee when using the GAI tool as when not using it." (p. 12)
Can I pass the cost of an AI tool on to the client?
Sometimes. AI built into everyday software is overhead, but a per-use, third-party tool bought for one client's matter can be billed at actual cost.
The opinion contrasts a grammar checker in word-processing software (overhead) with a per-use contract-review tool (a billable expense) on p. 13. The basis for any AI charge must be explained to the client in advance, preferably in writing.
You may not charge clients for learning a tool you will use regularly:
"a lawyer may not charge a client to learn about how to use a GAI tool or service that the lawyer will regularly use for clients" (p. 14)
What happens if I file something with fake AI citations?
You risk breaching three rules: the duty to bring only non-frivolous claims (Rule 3.1), the duty of candor to the court (Rule 3.3), and the ban on misrepresentation (Rule 8.4(c)). The opinion says even an honest mistake can count as a misrepresentation.
"Even an unintentional misstatement to a court can involve a misrepresentation under Rule 8.4(c). Therefore, output from a GAI tool must be carefully reviewed to ensure that the assertions made to the court are not false." (p. 10)
Before filing, review the output, including its citations and analysis, and check the local court rules on AI disclosure (p. 10, n. 47). For how courts have punished these errors, see Sanctions and court rules.
Does my firm need an AI policy?
Yes. Under Rules 5.1 and 5.3, managing lawyers must set clear policies on permitted AI use, and supervisors must make sure lawyers and staff are trained in its ethical and practical use.
"Managerial lawyers must establish clear policies regarding the law firm's permissible use of GAI" (p. 10)
How should I vet an AI vendor?
Treat it like any other outsourced provider. Check its security, its confidentiality terms, how long it keeps data, and whether it will tell you about a breach.
The opinion's vendor checklist (p. 11) includes whether the tool "retains information submitted by the lawyer before and after the discontinuation of services or asserts proprietary rights to the information," and whether the lawyer "will be notified in the event of a breach or service of process regarding production of client information."
Does Opinion 512 create new rules for AI?
No. It applies duties lawyers already have, and most of its conclusions would apply to any technology. Our reading: the core duty is technology-neutral: verify everything you file and protect what your client tells you.
Quotations are copied from the opinion PDF. The americanbar.org link above is the official copy; an Internet Archive copy of the same file is also available. In one quotation (pp. 3-4), the opinion's dashes are shown as hyphens.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026. This is general information, not legal advice.