AI ethics for lawyers: frequently asked questions
Is it ethical for lawyers to use ChatGPT or other AI tools?
Yes, if you meet your existing duties. No national rule bans generative AI, and ABA Formal Opinion 512 applies the Model Rules on competence, confidentiality, communication, fees, candor and supervision to it.
Source: ABA Formal Opinion 512 (July 29, 2024).
Do I have to tell my client I am using AI?
Sometimes. Under Opinion 512 you must disclose if the client asks, if their terms require it, if their information goes into the tool, if it affects the fee, or if AI output will shape a significant decision. Some states do not require disclosure of routine use, such as research.
Source: Opinion 512, p. 8; Kentucky KBA E-457; North Carolina 2024 FEO 1.
Do I need client consent to put client information into AI?
For self-learning tools, Opinion 512 says informed consent is required first, and a boilerplate engagement-letter clause is not sufficient. States vary: Texas, for example, does not make consent mandatory if you are reasonably sure the tool keeps information confidential.
Source: Opinion 512, p. 7; Texas Opinion 705.
Can I bill clients for time saved by AI?
Not on an hourly bill. Hourly billers may charge only for time actually spent, such as writing prompts and reviewing output, and Texas and Washington say the same in nearly the same words. For flat fees, Opinion 512 says "it may be unreasonable under Rule 1.5 for the lawyer to charge the same flat fee when using the GAI tool as when not using it" (p. 12).
Source: Opinion 512, p. 12; Texas Opinion 705; WSBA AO 202505.
Can I charge clients for AI tools?
AI built into everyday software is overhead. A per-use, third-party tool bought for one client's matter can be billed at actual cost if you explain the basis in advance, and you may not charge clients to learn a tool you will use regularly.
Source: Opinion 512, pp. 13-14.
What happens if AI makes up a case citation in my brief?
You can be sanctioned. Penalties so far range from a $5,000 fine in Mata v. Avianca (2023) to about $110,000 and dismissal with prejudice in Couvrette v. Wisnovsky (2026, as reported by the ABA Journal), and include disqualification, bar referral and suspension.
Source: Sanctions and court rules; Mata sanctions order.
Do courts require lawyers to disclose AI use in filings?
Some judges and courts do, through standing orders or local rules that require disclosure, certification that citations were checked, or both. Others, like the Fifth Circuit, have declined to adopt an AI-specific rule, so check the assigned judge's practices and local rules before each filing.
Source: Judge Baylson's standing order; Fletcher v. Experian, p. 3.
Are my AI chats protected by attorney-client privilege?
Not necessarily. In United States v. Heppner (S.D.N.Y., February 2026), Judge Rakoff reportedly held that a defendant's own chats with a consumer AI tool were neither privileged nor work product, partly because the provider's privacy policy allowed disclosure. The ruling, as reported, did not decide whether enterprise tools or AI used at a lawyer's direction would be treated differently.
Source: Proskauer; Harvard Law Review blog. Secondary sources.
Does deleting a chat mean the AI company no longer has it?
Not always. In the New York Times copyright case, a federal court ordered OpenAI in May 2025 to preserve output logs that would otherwise be deleted, including chats users had deleted; OpenAI says Enterprise, Edu and Zero Data Retention API customers were exempt. The ongoing duty ended on September 26, 2025.
Source: OpenAI; Duane Morris; Confidentiality and privilege.
Does my law firm need an AI policy?
Yes. Opinion 512 says managerial lawyers "must establish clear policies regarding the law firm's permissible use of GAI," and supervisors must train lawyers and staff. New Jersey's Supreme Court adds that a policy is "not a 'safe harbor.'"
Source: Opinion 512, p. 10; New Jersey Notice to the Bar, Mar. 30, 2026.
Choosing an AI tool
Can I put client files into ChatGPT?
Only after you know who can see them. Opinion 512 says to read the tool's Terms of Use and privacy policy to "learn who has access to the information that the lawyer inputs into the tool," and that self-learning tools need the client's informed consent first (p. 7). Plans differ: ChatGPT Enterprise and Claude Enterprise both say they do not train on your business data unless you opt in. A 2025 court order also required OpenAI to preserve consumer ChatGPT logs, including deleted chats, for several months; OpenAI says Enterprise customers were exempt (details).
Which AI tools keep client files private?
Look for a tool that does not train on your data, does not keep your prompts and files, and gives your firm a space no other customer shares, then confirm each point in the vendor's own terms. Faradex, a private AI workspace for small and mid-sized firms that handle confidential client work, says files and conversations are held in memory and are gone when the Workspace is reset, and that they are never used to train AI, and each firm gets its own Workspace on dedicated infrastructure (faradex.ai/security). For other vendors' own terms, see AI providers for law firms.
What is the best private AI for a small law firm?
Look for published pricing, no IT setup, no training on your data and no retention of your files. Faradex is built for that case: pricing is published at faradex.ai/pricing, starting with a one-person plan, and no IT team is needed. Harvey and Legora are sold by quote. Whatever you choose, run it through the checklist first.
Last reviewed November 9, 2026. This is general information, not legal advice.